Article made by:

Logo

Grandparents vs Daycare: How to Decide

Infants

Grandparent holding a sleeping baby

Grandparents vs Daycare: How to Decide

Updated November 2026.

Grandparent care and daycare can both be good for young children. Grandparents usually offer one-on-one attention, deep trust and flexible hours. Daycare offers trained teachers, other children to play with, a planned day and licensing oversight. The right choice depends on your child's age, the grandparent's health and energy, and how well you agree on rules. Many families combine the two.

Grandparents are a big part of American child care. In a U.S. Census Bureau report on spring 2010, 30% of preschoolers were regularly cared for by a grandparent.

Pros of grandparent care

Cons of grandparent care

Pros and cons of daycare

Licensed centers have trained staff, set teacher-child ratios, regular inspections and a daily routine with play, stories, music and outdoor time. Children learn to share, follow group routines and make friends, which helps with the move to preschool and kindergarten.

The downsides: fixed hours, closures, more colds in the first year, and less one-on-one time than with a grandparent. Some children take a few weeks to settle in.

What research says

The NICHD Study of Early Child Care and Youth Development followed more than 1,300 children from birth. It found that family factors, such as parenting and the home environment, had a bigger influence on children's development than the type of child care. Higher-quality care was linked to somewhat better language and early learning, and very long hours in group care were linked to slightly more behavior problems. The effects of child care type were small. See Daycare Guilt: What the Research Really Shows.

That suggests the quality of the care, and the relationship, matter more than the setting. A warm, engaged grandparent and a warm, well-run daycare can both serve a child well.

Questions to help you decide

  1. Can the grandparent handle the physical work for the hours you need, for a year or more?
  2. Do you agree on safe sleep, car seats, food, screens and discipline?
  3. What's the plan when the grandparent is sick or away?
  4. Does your child need more peer play or more one-on-one time right now?
  5. Will you pay the grandparent, and is everyone comfortable with that?

Combining grandparents and daycare

Many families use grandparents for the baby year, then switch to daycare or preschool around age 2 or 3. Others split the week, with two or three days at daycare and the rest with a grandparent. Grandparents also make a great backup for daycare sick days. See Backup Child Care: Plans for Sick Days and Closures.

If a grandparent cares for your baby

Share current safety guidance. The Safe to Sleep campaign recommends placing babies on their backs, on a firm, flat surface, with no pillows, blankets or bumpers. Review car seat rules, safe medicine storage and your pediatrician's number together. See Illinois Car Seat Laws 2026: Age, Height and Weight Rules.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better for a baby to be with grandparents or in daycare?

Both can work well. Research suggests the quality of care and the home environment matter more than the type of care.

What are the downsides of grandparents watching kids?

Physical demands on the grandparent, no backup when they're sick, disagreements over rules and fewer chances to play with other children.

Can grandparents get paid for child care in Illinois?

Many families pay grandparents privately. Some families who qualify for the Child Care Assistance Program can use it to pay a relative caregiver.

When should a child switch from grandparent care to daycare?

Many families switch around age 2 or 3, when children benefit from more peer play and structured activities.

Visiting Children's Land

Children's Land has served Chicagoland families since 2005, with programs from our New Beginnings Program for babies to pre-K. Parents can watch classrooms on monitors at the entrance. Ask your location's director about a visit, and bring along anyone who helps with care. Find a location or contact us.

Related reading: What Is the Best Age to Start Daycare?

What to read next